1. Rate every player from 1 to 5
Use one scale for everyone: 1 is new to the sport, 3 is a typical rec player, 5 is among the strongest in the age group. Rate returning players from last season’s coaches and new players from an evaluation day.
Without an evaluation, ask parents one plain question about years played and level, and treat the answer as a rough guess. Keep the ratings with the people who build the teams. Coaches receive rosters, not scores.
2. Place the fixed players first
Before dealing, put each coach’s own child on that coach’s team, and the same for assistants if your policy allows it. Write their ratings against the team total so you can see how the team already stands.
Then deal the rest, starting with whichever team has the lowest total. A coach whose child is a 5 gets fewer strong players from the snake, and that is the point: the team ends up level, not stacked.
3. Sort and deal in a snake
Sort the remaining players from highest rating to lowest. Deal them one at a time down the list: team one, team two, team three, then reverse, team three, team two, team one, and keep zigzagging. The team that picks last in one pass picks first in the next.
The reversal is what makes it fair. Dealing 1, 2, 3, 1, 2, 3 would always hand team one the strongest player of every group of three. The snake cancels that out, and no team is always first to choose.
4. Work a small example
Twelve players, three teams, ratings from best: 5, 5, 4, 4, 4, 3, 3, 3, 2, 2, 2, 1. The deal gives team one the 5, 3, 3 and 1, team two the 5, 4, 3 and 2, and team three the 4, 4, 2 and 2. Totals are 12, 14 and 12.
Swap team two’s 4 for team one’s 3 and the totals become 13, 13 and 12. With 38 points across three teams the target is about 12.7 each, so that is as even as it can get. Always add up every team’s total after dealing, and before anyone is told, since a quick check catches most mistakes.
5. Balance age, experience and key positions
A single rating hides things. Spread the oldest players in the age group, children new to the sport, and anyone who can play goalkeeper, pitcher or catcher, so one team does not collect all of them. Check that each team has enough of those players to cover a game.
Count each team’s players by birth year or grade, and by gender if the division uses it. Roster sizes should be within one player of each other. Give any extra player to the team with the lowest total.
6. Set a policy for requests
Decide before registration how you handle friend, sibling and carpool requests, and say so on the form. A common rule is one friend request per player, granted when it keeps the teams balanced. Mutual requests go first. Keeping twins and same-division siblings together is a common rule too.
Call them requests, not promises. Apply the policy the same way to every family, including the children of board members. Carpool requests are practical and easy to grant when they fit, but they come after balance.
7. Check the totals, then publish
Add up each team, compare it with the target, and look at the lists of strong players, goalies and oldest players one more time. Ask a second person who has no child on any team to read through the final lists.
Publish every team at the same time, with the coach’s contact and the first practice, and give a short window for hardship requests. When a parent asks for a move, remind them that a swap means changing another child’s team too, and offer a one-for-one trade for a real conflict.
Doing this on FullEleven
FullEleven builds balanced teams from your ratings and requests.
FullEleven for recreational leagues
Reviewed November 2026. General information, not legal advice. Check your state’s rules and your governing body’s requirements.