Skip to content
Guides

Player evaluation criteria for youth sports

Good player evaluation criteria are four to six skills an evaluator can see, such as dribbling or catching, each scored on a 1 to 5 scale where every number has a written meaning. Use at least two evaluators, score players by pinnie number instead of name, average the scores, and leave out anything you did not watch.

Pick four to six skills you can see

Choose skills that show up in a drill or a short game, and that you can score in a few seconds. More than six and evaluators fill in the sheet from memory. For soccer: first touch, passing accuracy, dribbling under pressure, shooting and positioning without the ball.

For basketball: dribbling with both hands, passing, shooting form, defensive stance and footwork, and rebounding. For baseball and softball: fielding ground balls, throwing accuracy, making contact at the plate, base running and knowing what to do before the pitch.

Write what each number means

A scale only works when evaluators share it. A common set of anchors: 1, cannot do it yet in a game-like setting. 2, does it sometimes when there is no pressure. 3, does it correctly most of the time in drills. 4, does it correctly at game speed.

5, does it well at game speed under pressure and with either foot or hand. Say that 3 is a typical player and that 5 should be rare. Print the anchors on the sheet so evaluators read them while they score, not just in the briefing.

Score numbers, not names

Give every player a numbered pinnie or bib at check-in and have evaluators write down the number only. Evaluators then score what they see, not whose child it is or who played well last year.

Keep the list that matches numbers to names with the registrar or one organizer, not at the field. Add a column for anything an evaluator must know, such as “left-footed” or “played goalkeeper”, as a note and not a score.

Use several evaluators and score on the spot

Use at least two evaluators for each group, and three if you can. Do not use anyone who has a child in the group. Each evaluator works alone and writes scores right after each drill, before anyone talks.

If evaluators discuss players while play is going on, the loudest opinion wins. Keep discussion for the end, and use it only for large gaps between scores, where a player may simply have been missed.

Combine the scores

Add up each evaluator’s score for a skill and divide by the number of evaluators. If three evaluators give ball control 3, 4 and 4, the skill scores 3.7. Add the skill scores for each player to get the total.

If two evaluators differ by two or more points on a skill, have them both watch that player once more before the total is final. Rank by total only after that. A tie is a reason to look at the notes, not to flip a coin.

Leave out what you cannot score

Do not score height, size, last season’s team, the parent’s role in the league, shyness or how much a child talks. Do not score attitude unless you define it as something visible, such as running back to position or helping a teammate up.

Do not score a skill you did not see. A player who was ill or injured gets a make-up session or a note, not a low number. In a rec league these scores balance teams. In a competitive tryout they decide offers, so say that up front.

Copy this scoring sheet

Across the top: evaluator name, date, age group, session. Columns, left to right: pinnie number, then one column for each of the four to six skills, then notes, then a total column that the organizer fills in. One row per player, filled in left to right as each drill ends. Leave a skill blank if you did not see it.

At the bottom, print the 1 to 5 anchors in one line each. Evaluators score in the skill columns only. They do not total. The organizer adds the sheets together at the end, so that no evaluator’s sum influences what the others write down.

Doing this on FullEleven

FullEleven handles tryout sign-up, evaluator scoring and team offers.

Tryouts on FullEleven

Reviewed November 2026. General information, not legal advice. Check your state’s rules and your governing body’s requirements.

Questions

How many skills should a player evaluation score?

Four to six. That is enough to tell players apart and few enough that an evaluator can score each one while play continues.

Can parents see their child’s evaluation scores?

That is the league’s choice. Decide it before the evaluation and say it in the registration details. Many leagues keep scores private and give families the outcome, such as the team or the offer.

What if a player misses the evaluation?

Offer a make-up session if there is a second date, or use last season’s coach rating with a note that it is not from this season. Do not give a missed player the lowest score.

Your next season starts here

Set up your league in about 10 minutes. Free for your league, with setup help from a real person.

Parent or coach? Find your league.