1. Know the two separate steps
Becoming a nonprofit has two parts that people mix up. The first is state incorporation: the league becomes a legal organization under your state’s nonprofit law. The second is federal tax exemption: the IRS recognizes the league as exempt. A league can have the first without the second.
501(c)(3) is the section of the US tax code for charitable organizations. Whether a given league qualifies is for the IRS to decide from its application, and what your state exempts is decided by your state. Plan for some time and for fees at both levels.
2. Incorporate in your state
File articles of incorporation with the state office that registers organizations, often the Secretary of State. You will usually give a name, an address, a purpose and sometimes a registered agent. Forms, fees and the minimum number of directors differ by state.
Search for name conflicts first, and pick a name that will still fit the league in years. An attorney, or your state’s own instructions for nonprofit corporations, can walk you through it. Keep the filed documents: the IRS and your bank will ask for them.
3. Form a board and write bylaws
Bylaws are the league’s rules for itself: how many directors, how they are chosen, how long they serve, how meetings and votes work, what counts as a conflict of interest, and how the bylaws change. Your state may set minimums, so read its nonprofit law or ask an attorney.
Many leagues elect at least a president, a treasurer and a secretary (your state may require specific officers), and keep minutes of every board vote. A director who is paid, or whose child is affected by a decision, should say so and step out of that vote.
4. Get an EIN and a bank account
An EIN is the league’s federal tax identification number. The league applies for it directly with the IRS, and it is usually needed to open a bank account and to apply for tax exemption. Keep the confirmation letter with the incorporation papers.
Open the account in the league’s name, not a person’s, using the EIN and the incorporation documents, and put two board members on it. Any money collected before the account existed should be moved into it and recorded.
5. Apply for federal tax exemption
To be recognized as a 501(c)(3), the league files an application with the IRS describing its purpose, activities, finances and governance, and pays a user fee. The IRS has a longer form and, for some small organizations, a shorter one. An accountant can tell you which fits.
Ask your accountant what you may tell donors and sponsors before the IRS responds, since the rules on that are specific. When the determination letter arrives, keep it: banks, sponsors, field owners and grant makers often ask for a copy.
6. Register with the state and keep filing
After incorporating, states often have further steps: an annual report to the state, registration before asking the public for donations in some states, and, in some states, sales-tax or property-tax exemptions that must be requested separately. Ask an accountant or attorney which apply in your state.
Tax-exempt organizations generally have annual filing duties with the IRS, and which form applies depends on the league’s size, so ask your accountant what applies. Put every due date, state and federal, on the board’s calendar.
7. Set basic money controls
Require two signers on checks and large payments, and don’t let the person who records the money be the only person who can move it. Pay from the league’s account only: no personal payment apps and no cash kept at home.
Have the treasurer give the board a monthly report with the opening balance, money in, money out and closing balance, and attach the bank statement. Someone other than the treasurer should look at that statement. A volunteer who is not on the board can do it.
Doing this on FullEleven
FullEleven collects fees straight to your league’s bank account and exports every registration and payment, which gives a new nonprofit’s treasurer clean records from the first season.
Reviewed November 2026. General information, not legal advice. Check your state’s rules and your governing body’s requirements.