1. Say what you’re looking for
Before the tryout, tell families the dates, the age groups, how many teams and roster spots there are, the skills you will score and what the season will cost. Surprises after an offer are what sour a tryout.
2. Register in advance
Take sign-ups online with a waiver and medical details, so check-in on the day is a name and a number, not a clipboard and a queue.
3. Score by number
Give each player a numbered bib and have evaluators score numbers, not names. Score a short list of skills on a simple scale, such as 1 to 5. Long forms don’t get filled in properly while play is going on.
4. Use independent evaluators
Use at least two evaluators per group, and avoid anyone with a child trying out in it. Run drills and small-sided games, since some players show better in one than the other, and offer a second date for anyone who was ill.
5. Build teams, then check them
Rank by the combined scores, then let the coaches look at the edges of each roster: positions, a keeper, players who were absent. Record why any player was moved against their score.
6. Tell everyone at once
Send offers and the news that a player wasn’t placed at the same time, in writing, with a deadline to accept. Give families who weren’t placed a next step: another team, a development program or the date of the next tryout.
Doing this on FullEleven
FullEleven runs tryouts with online sign-up, check-in numbers, scoring by number on evaluators’ phones, and offers families accept and pay for online.
Reviewed November 2026. General information, not legal advice. Check your state’s rules and your governing body’s requirements.