1. List your must-do jobs
Before you look at any product, write the jobs your league does each season: registration, taking payment, waivers, teams, a schedule, referees, messages to families, standings. Mark each as must-have or nice-to-have. Products differ in what they are built for, so a job list keeps you from judging on feature count alone.
Add the jobs that cost your volunteers the most hours, such as chasing payments, answering the same schedule question or rescheduling after rain. Software that fixes those three is worth more than a long feature list, and you can test it against them.
2. Work out the total cost per player
Price each option for your own numbers, and add card processing, which the payment company charges on top. Take two made-up fee models, a flat $4 fee and a 3 percent fee. On a $150 registration the flat fee is $4.00 and the percentage is $4.50. On a $400 registration the flat fee is still $4.00 and the percentage is $12.00.
Multiply by players. For 100 players at $150, the flat fee costs $400 and the percentage $450. At $400 each, it is $400 against $1,200. The two are equal at about $133. Also ask about setup, extra admins, and charges for exports.
3. Check who pays and where the money sits
Ask whether the family can pay the software fee, the league can, or either, and whether the family sees the full total before paying. Then ask where the money goes: straight to the league’s bank account, or into the vendor’s account first.
Money held by a vendor can arrive days or weeks later. Ask how many days from a family’s payment to your bank, what happens in a refund or a chargeback, and who can see the payouts.
4. Test the parent experience on a phone
Most families register on a phone, often in a parking lot. Open your trial registration on a phone and finish it as a parent would: find the link, choose a child, sign the waiver, pay, get the receipt. Count the screens and the typing.
Ask a parent who has never seen it to try on their own phone, and watch without helping. Note where they hesitate or go back, because that is where real registrations will be lost, and ask the vendor whether it can be fixed.
5. Check import, export and privacy
You should be able to import last year’s families from a spreadsheet and export everything, including signed forms and payment records, whenever you want, without a fee. Test both in the trial. A league that cannot take its own data and leave cannot say no when prices change.
Read how the vendor handles children’s information, who can see it and how roles work, so a coach sees a roster and not everything. Ask for the answers in writing, and keep them with your notes.
6. Test the support
Send a real question before you sign, one you would send in the rush before registration opens, and note how fast and how well you are answered. Ask about hours, whether you get a person, and whether support costs extra.
Ask what happens on a Saturday morning during games, when a field problem or a payment error needs an answer in minutes. Many volunteer leagues are busiest on weekends, so a support desk that closes on Friday does not fit them.
7. Run a two-week trial with a real program
Pick one real program, such as a fall division or a camp, and run it end to end: set up the program, open registration to a small group, take real payments, build a team and a schedule, and send a message.
At the end, ask four people what went wrong: the registrar, the treasurer, a coach and a parent. Compare what they found against your must-do list and your cost table, and decide with the board.
Doing this on FullEleven
FullEleven covers registration, payments, scheduling, teams and messaging for a league with no subscription or contract.
Reviewed November 2026. General information, not legal advice. Check your state’s rules and your governing body’s requirements.